The Paradigm Shift in Government Budget Management: A CiteSpace Knowledge Map based on Zero-Based Budgeting Research

Authors

  • Shiya Hu
  • Guoyu Mao

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.6981/FEM.202508_6(8).0017

Keywords:

Zero-based Budgeting; Knowledge Graphs; Budget Management.

Abstract

Research on the transformation of government budget paradigms, particularly Zero-Based Budgeting (ZBB) reforms, holds significant theoretical and practical implications for deepening fiscal system reforms and enhancing the modernization of national governance capabilities. This study employs bibliometric methods, utilizing CiteSpace software to conduct keyword co-occurrence and clustering analysis on 247 relevant documents indexed in China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), systematically examining the publication sequence, annual distribution, core author groups, keyword clustering characteristics, emergence intensity, and evolutionary trends of the literature. The study found that the popularity of zero-based budgeting research continues to rise, and related practices have entered a stage of in-depth reform. Key factors such as the institutional environment, interest structure, and social demand constitute the current research hotspots. Future research will focus on three major directions for in-depth exploration: “digitalization” and “smartization” technology empowering budget reform, in-depth integration of the entire budget performance management process, and central-local coordination and regional resource optimization mechanisms. Based on the above analysis, the government should prioritize promoting the transformation of budget management models and exploring specific implementation pathways for deepening zero-based budget reform. The core lies in strengthening performance-oriented goals and optimizing the allocation of fiscal resources, with a focus on breaking through three structural bottlenecks: “reliance on historical data,” “policy rigidity,” and “project continuity.” This will effectively enhance the efficiency of fiscal resource allocation and the effectiveness of fiscal fund utilization.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

[1] Chen Haiyan. Insights into Zero-Based Budgeting [J]. Accounting and Finance Bulletin, 2009, (11): 110-111.

[2] Cui Huiyu, Xu Suiwei, and Chu Wenyue. Research on Deepening Zero-Based Budgeting Reform and Innovative Collaborative Budget Management [J]. Fiscal Research, 2025, (01): 26-38.

[3] Liu Yongquan. Eight Major Reforms in Budget Management of Government Departments and Units in China [J]. Accounting Friend, 2025, (05): 2-7.

[4] Ma Caichen, Zhu Wenyin. A Study on the Basic Conditions for Transitioning from Traditional Performance Budgeting to New Performance Budgeting [J]. Fiscal Research, 2025, (01): 14-25.

[5] Zhao Xia. A Discussion on Issues in Financial Budget Management in Higher Education Institutions [J]. Accounting and Finance Bulletin, 2015, (20): 127-128.

[6] Zhao Shanqing. A Dialectical Consideration of the Application of Zero-Based Budgeting Methods in Higher Education Institutions [J]. Accounting and Finance Monthly, 2014, (04): 112-113.

[7] Zeng Linghui, Zheng Shiqiao. The Impact of Zero-Based Budgeting on Budget Preparation Looseness [J]. New Accounting, 2010, (07): 9-11.

[8] Xiao Peng, Wang Yaqi, Tao Chang. Budget Performance Management and High-Quality Economic Development: An Analysis from the Perspective of Fiscal Resource Allocation [J]. Exploration of Economic Issues, 2024, (07): 15-30.

[9] Gu Bingwei. A Retrospective and Reflections on Government Budget Reform [J]. Business Era, 2012, (12): 96-97.

[10] Xiao Peng, Liu Yawei. Local Practices of Zero-Based Budgeting Reform [J]. China Finance, 2024, (23): 51-52.

[11] Ma Caichen, Sun Xiaoxue. A Study on Local Zero-Based Budget Reform Based on Performance Considerations [J]. Economic Horizons, 2024, (02): 107-115.

[12] Huang Guoming. Reflections on Deepening Departmental Budget Reform at the Provincial Level in the Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region [J]. Economic Research Reference, 2010, (53): 24-27+36.

[13] Wang Zhenyu, Hou Peilin. Local Practices, Constraints, and Improvements in Zero-Based Budgeting Reform [J]. Fiscal Science, 2025, (02): 19-28.

[14] Gan Zhiyong. Reflections on the Practice of Departmental Budget Reform in Yundong County [J]. Accounting and Finance Bulletin, 2012, (29): 155-156.

[15] Li Wei. Research on Departmental Budget Management in Administrative and Public Institutions [J]. Accounting Research, 2010, (10): 10-12.

[16] Li Hong. Research on the Implementation of Zero-Based Budgeting Reform in China [J]. Enterprise Economy, 2014, (05): 164-167.

[17] Peng Jiajun. Zero-Based Budgeting: Understanding Its Essential Characteristics and Enhancing Its Application Effectiveness [J]. Finance and Accounting, 2018, (16): 54-56.

[18] Lyu Wei, Liu Xingqi. Deepening Zero-Based Budgeting Reform: Practical Explorations and Reform Strategies [J]. Learning and Practice, 2025, (01): 63-71+2.

[19] Zhang Ping, Gou Yannan, Pang Qingyue, et al. Constructing New Assumptions for Zero-Based Budgeting: A Synergistic Exploration of Theoretical Framework and Chinese Practice [J]. Fiscal Research, 2025, (03): 18-29.

[20] Song Guoxin, Shen Dongming, Dong Xue. Deepening Zero-Based Budgeting Reform in China: Challenges and Countermeasures [J]. Fiscal Science, 2025, (02): 29-37.

[21] Wu Xuefen. Exploring Digital Reform in Local Finance: A Case Study of City A in Zhejiang Province [J]. Local Finance Research, 2021, (04): 35-39.

[22] Li Wenbin, Han Xiaocui. The Practice and Optimization of Digital Empowerment in Budget Performance Management: An Examination Based on Digital Finance [J]. Learning Forum, 2024, (06): 70-77.

[23] Lin Jing. A Study on the Evaluation of Budget Governance Efficiency in China's Local Finance under the Digital Government Context: Based on the DEA-Malmquist Model [J]. Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology (Social Sciences Edition), 2024, 26(04): 152-160.

[24] Zeng Linghui, Chen Weiqing. On the Integration of Zero-Based Budgeting and Performance Budgeting into a Budgeting Methodology System [J]. Accounting and Finance Bulletin, 2010, (32): 119-120.

[25] Zhang Hui. Practices, Challenges, and Optimization Pathways in the Reform of Integrated Budget Management [J]. Accounting and Finance Monthly, 2023, 44(04): 115-122.

Downloads

Published

2025-08-13

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Hu, S., & Mao, G. (2025). The Paradigm Shift in Government Budget Management: A CiteSpace Knowledge Map based on Zero-Based Budgeting Research. Frontiers in Economics and Management, 6(8), 200-214. https://doi.org/10.6981/FEM.202508_6(8).0017